Social Security Disability Lawsuits: Your Guide to Winning Benefits

Our team at Tort Advisor comprises seasoned attorneys specializing in Social Security Disability Insurance (SSDI). We partner with legal professionals nationwide to deliver reliable, current information to our readers.

Legally Reviewed
This content has been authored and verified by Tort Advisor’s legal experts for accuracy and clarity. It is not a substitute for personalized legal advice. Learn more about our firm at Tort Advisor.

Fact-Checked
Tort Advisor ensures the information provided is accurate and up-to-date. For tailored legal advice, contact us online. This is not attorney advice.

If your Social Security Disability Insurance (SSDI) claim was denied, you may be eligible to file a lawsuit to secure the benefits you deserve. Recent trends show a rise in SSDI lawsuits as claimants challenge denials, often due to strict eligibility rules or administrative errors. These lawsuits aim to hold the Social Security Administration (SSA) accountable for fair evaluations.

This page provides essential insights for those considering legal action, including updates on SSDI litigation and potential outcomes. Timing is critical—denied claims have strict appeal deadlines. If you’ve been denied SSDI benefits, don’t delay. Call us or contact us online for a free case review today.

Social Security Disability Insurance (SSDI) is a federal program providing financial support to individuals unable to work due to a severe, long-term disability. Funded through payroll taxes, SSDI offers monthly payments to eligible workers who have earned sufficient work credits and meet the SSA’s strict disability criteria.

SSDI benefits are designed for individuals whose medical conditions prevent substantial gainful activity (SGA) for at least 12 months or are expected to result in death. Unlike Supplemental Security Income (SSI), SSDI eligibility depends on your work history and contributions to Social Security, not financial need.

Common conditions qualifying for SSDI include:

• Musculoskeletal disorders (e.g., arthritis, back injuries)
• Neurological conditions (e.g., Parkinson’s, epilepsy)
• Mental health disorders (e.g., depression, PTSD)
• Cardiovascular issues (e.g., heart failure)
• Cancer and blood disorders

Despite its importance, SSDI claims face high denial rates—over 60% of initial applications are rejected. Many denials stem from insufficient medical evidence or failure to meet technical requirements. This has led to a surge in SSDI lawsuits as claimants seek to overturn unfair decisions.

The SSA’s approval process for SSDI began with the Social Security Act of 1935, which later expanded to include disability benefits in 1956. Over decades, the program evolved to address growing needs, but strict eligibility standards remain a barrier for many.

Early SSDI applications faced scrutiny due to limited medical evaluation methods. By the 1980s, the SSA refined its disability criteria, focusing on medical evidence and work capacity. However, concerns persisted about inconsistent approvals and administrative errors, prompting reforms like the Disability Benefits Reform Act of 1984.

Today, the SSA evaluates claims using a five-step sequential process:

1. Substantial Gainful Activity: Are you earning above the SGA limit ($1,620/month for non-blind individuals in 2025)?
2. Severity of Condition: Is your impairment severe enough to limit basic work activities?
3. Listed Impairments: Does your condition meet or equal an SSA-listed disability?
4. Past Work: Can you perform your previous job?
5. Other Work: Can you adjust to other work given your age, education, and skills?

Despite these standards, denials remain common, often leading to lawsuits when claimants believe the SSA overlooked critical evidence.

Since its inception, SSDI has supported millions of Americans. In 2024, approximately 8.1 million people received SSDI benefits, with an average monthly payment of $1,539. The program is particularly vital for older workers, veterans, and those with chronic conditions.

SSDI usage peaked in the early 2010s but has since stabilized due to stricter evaluations and economic shifts. The program remains a lifeline for those unable to work, though navigating its complexities often requires legal assistance.

SSDI denials occur for various reasons, often tied to the SSA’s stringent criteria. Common causes include:

• Insufficient Medical Evidence: Lack of detailed medical records proving disability severity.
• Excessive Income: Earning above the SGA threshold disqualifies applicants.
• Short-Term Conditions: Disabilities expected to last less than 12 months.
• Administrative Errors: Misinterpretation of evidence or procedural mistakes.

Denials can have significant consequences, including financial hardship and delayed medical care. Fortunately, the SSA offers an appeals process, and lawsuits can follow if appeals fail.

Disability symptoms vary by condition but may include:

• Chronic pain or mobility issues
• Cognitive or memory impairments
• Severe fatigue or weakness
• Vision or hearing loss
• Psychological distress (e.g., anxiety, depression)

These symptoms often interfere with daily activities and employment, forming the basis for SSDI claims. Proper documentation is critical to demonstrate their impact.

The SSA requires comprehensive medical evidence to evaluate claims:

• Medical Records: Doctor’s notes, test results, and treatment history.
• Consultative Examinations: SSA-requested exams to assess condition severity.
• Functional Assessments: Evaluations of your ability to perform work-related tasks.

Failure to provide sufficient evidence often leads to denials, making thorough documentation essential.

Treatment for SSDI-eligible conditions varies:

• Medication: To manage symptoms like pain or mental health issues.
• Surgery: For conditions like spinal injuries or joint disorders.
• Therapy: Physical or psychological therapy to improve function.

Prognosis depends on the condition’s severity and response to treatment. Chronic or progressive disorders often strengthen SSDI claims due to their long-term impact.

A 2023 SSA report noted that 35% of denied claimants appeal, with many proceeding to lawsuits when appeals fail. Studies, such as one from the Government Accountability Office, highlight inconsistencies in SSA evaluations, including overlooked medical evidence and regional disparities in approval rates. These issues fuel litigation as claimants seek fair hearings.

The SSA is required to fairly evaluate claims and provide clear denial explanations. When it fails to do so, lawsuits arise. Common claims in SSDI lawsuits include:

• Improper Denial: The SSA overlooked critical medical or vocational evidence.
• Procedural Errors: Failure to follow SSA guidelines during evaluation.
• Unfair Hearings: Bias or inadequate review by Administrative Law Judges (ALJs).

Lawsuits aim to secure benefits and hold the SSA accountable for errors.

You may qualify for an SSDI lawsuit if:

• Your claim was denied or benefits were unfairly reduced.
• You have sufficient work credits (typically 40, with 20 earned in the last 10 years).
• Your disability meets SSA criteria and is supported by medical evidence.

While most SSDI lawsuits are individual, some cases involve class actions addressing systemic SSA issues, such as discriminatory evaluation practices. Multidistrict Litigation (MDL) is less common but may consolidate similar claims for efficiency. Benefits include:

• Coordinated legal strategies
• Shared evidence collection
• Consistent rulings across cases

Bellwether trials in 2025 are expected to shape SSDI litigation outcomes, influencing settlements.

Many SSDI lawsuits settle before trial to avoid lengthy appeals. Settlements typically include:

• Backdated benefits from the disability onset date.
• Monthly payments based on work history.
• Coverage of medical expenses or legal fees.

Settlements vary based on case strength and evidence. Legal representation is crucial to maximize outcomes.

Undiagnosed conditions may qualify for SSDI if they meet SSA criteria. Watch for:

• Persistent pain or fatigue
• Cognitive or emotional difficulties
• Mobility or sensory impairments

Early medical evaluation strengthens claims and supports legal action.

While speculative, average SSDI lawsuit settlements range from $20,000 to $100,000, depending on:

1. Disability Severity: More debilitating conditions yield higher awards.
2. Back Pay: Longer delays increase backdated benefits.
3. Economic Loss: Lost wages and medical costs boost settlements.
4. Age and Work History: Younger claimants or those with extensive work credits may receive more.
5. Legal Strength: Robust evidence and attorney expertise enhance payouts.

Settlements aim to provide financial relief and accountability for SSA errors.

Receiving a lump sum settlement from a personal injury or other lawsuit can affect SSDI benefits. According to Tort Advisor, settlements are considered “unearned income” by the SSA. If the settlement pushes your income above the SGA limit, your SSDI benefits may be reduced or terminated. However, proper legal planning, such as placing funds in a special needs trust, can protect eligibility. Consult an attorney to navigate these complexities.

Complete our short form on the right for a free case review with our SSDI experts.